ESPN’s ‘Get Up’ Made Up Jayson Tatum, Jaylen Brown Friction Based on a Smile

The Boston Celtics finished the regular season with the best record in the NBA at 64-18. Then they rolled through the Eastern Conference playoffs, losing just two games in three rounds on their way to their second NBA Finals in three seasons. You would think things were going pretty well in Boston, but if you tuned into Get Up this morning, you might think the team was about to unravel.

During Day 2 of the conversation about Jaylen Brown being named MVP of the Eastern Conference finals, they showed a clip of Brown receiving his trophy and highlighted Jayson Tatum smiling while he clapped for his longtime teammate. This was apparently Tatum being “shocked” and not excited like his teamamtes.

“I think a lot of people were surprised,” said Greenberg. “There was a lot of chatter online yesterday to whatever degree this is important and relevant about Jayson Tatum’s reaction. When Jaylen Brown wins that award in the moment that it happens, the rest of the team just goes crazy. And you were talking about it in our meeting earlier this morning. They’re all so genuinely… Look at them. They are just so genuinely excited for him and you did not seem to think that it was mirrored in Jayson Tatum.”

Greenberg then turned to Udonis Haslem, who twice says he thought Tatum was “shocked.” Again, the video clearly shows Tatum doing exactly what every other teammate is doing in the same video. He’s touching Brown in congratulations. He’s smiling. He’s clapping. He has the same look on his face that everyone else does. In order to imagine this being some kind negative reaction you would have to be someone with a vested interest in the Celtics failing. Conveniently, Get Up had one of those people on set today in Udonis Haslem.

What is ESPN thinking having Haslem, who played two decades for the Heat and is currently employed by the team, commenting on Miami’s most bitter rival? They’re putting him on national television to sow doubt in the public’s mind about how their stars feel about each other using a video of them celebrating a trip to the Finals. The fact that this came in the same episode that Haslem was worried about possibly tampering during a segment about LeBron James makes it an even more dubious decision.

While we probably shouldn’t be surprised that Haslem would try to say this, it’s downright amazing that Greenberg would not just humor him but set him up for it. There is literally nothing in this video that would suggest anything but joy, yet ESPN has Tatum lit up like he’s being identified in CCTV footage at a burglary trial.. All he’s doing is smiling!

The Ringer‘s Bill Simmons was among the many people to call Greenberg and ESPN out for this ridiculous editorial choice.

The worst part about all this is that there is still a week until the NBA Finals start. If this is what ESPN’s flagship morning show has turned to the morning after an actual Western Conference finals game we can’t be far from wondering whether Tatum or Brown will demand a trade first this offseason. Sure, they’ve played together for seven straight years, had a ton of success and both signed max contracts at every opportunity, but maybe they want more!

Maybe Pat Riley or Alonzo Mourning can join the show to discuss trade destinations next week.